Hep Girls. Chick Bands. Jazzgrrls. Each generation brings a new wave
of inspired women instrumentalists trying to break the jazz ceiling. There
are more female jazz players coming up than ever before, thanks to mentoring
programs such as the Sisters in Jazz sponsored by the International Association
for Jazz Education.
Yet the proliferation of women-focused jazz Web sites, books, discographies,
archives, jazz festivals, workshops, radio programs and magazine articles
seem to support the notion that it is still difficult for many women jazz
instrumentalists to find meaningful performance, composing and recording
opportunities. Certainly jazz fans can point to Toshiko Akiyoshi and Maria
Schneider, who have achieved international prominence as composers and
bandleaders. And swinging all-women ensembles such as Diva and Maiden Voyage
bring crowds to their feet. Yet the average jazz audience is still surprised
when a woman walks on stage as a side musician or non-vocal soloist.
Curious about what the scene is like for women jazzers in Europe, Windplayer
caught up with Hazel Leach and Christina Fuchs, co-leaders of the United
Women's Orchestra, a long-established group of 18 women who hail from four
countries. One of the few bigbands in Europe that performs new and original
compositions, their hallmark is an eclectic range of modern orchestral
jazz reflective of their cultural backgrounds. "It's always hard to label
your own music," Leach explains. "A nice word I hear a lot from audiences
and critics is 'narrative.' I like it because it agrees with my own idea
that a piece of music creates its own world in time and space- a story
in which events unfold, as (in) the form, a solo, a dialogue- and keeps
the listener involved until the last note."
The two tenor sax players met in 1992, at a big-band workshop for women
musicians in Frankfurt, Germany, sponsored by women's organization Frauen
machen Musik e.V. "I turned up at the first workshop with music specially
written for the occasion," recalls Leach, a native of Newcastle, England
who now resides and teaches at a conservatory in Arnhem, The Netherlands.
"A 'call for music' had been placed in a magazine. I met Christina there,
and since there wasn't a bandleader we agreed to share the position. We
got on well, the sharing formula seemed to be ideal, and.. the rest is
history."
Fuchs, from Cologne, Germany, was one of the organization's founding
members. She started out with straightforward goals. "I wanted two things-
to write for a large ensemble and to lead/conduct it." The workshop was
so enjoyable for all of the musicians that they decided to found the United
Women's Orchestra.
The ensemble currently rehearses two or three times per weekend. They
hold additional rehearsals prior to a concert, where they typically perform
two 45-minute sets. "New works have a priority," explains Fuchs. "We try
to split up 50/50 Leach's and my pieces, what fits in the program dramatically."
Leach states, "Our music is different to other big band stuff, and is an
important motivation for many of the players in the band. Also, because
it's original and improvised music, the band members have some say in how
the music is played."
One of the biggest surprises initially to the co-leaders in conducting
an all-women group was that rehearsals are much more democratic than those
of other ensembles. Leach elaborates, "Everyone in the band is much more
actively involved in discussing how the music should be played. This can
be time-consuming! But the advantage is that each player ensures 100-percent
involvement and satisfaction for herself. I was also pleasantly surprised
by the willingness (of the members) to spend time experimenting with musical
ideas."
Another bonus of working in a long-established group is that a network
of smaller groups has sprung up within and around the United Women's Orchestra.
"We have a double lineup and a vast array of subs collected over the years,"
explains Leach.
Reflecting on the importance of networking she says, "I think some
women bury themselves in the women's circuit, perhaps out of insecurity?
My advice to all women is to get out and work with everybody. A lot of
men are good players and unprejudiced too!".
The jazz scene in Europe is similar in several ways to the American
scene, namely negotiating enough money and having to explain how well-known
you are. Fuchs reports she and Leach also have to answer the question,
"Why an all-women band?" which perhaps is a positive sign that European
audiences are becoming accustomed to seeing more mixed-gender jazz ensembles.
Leach believes that overall the jazz scene is changing in Europe, not
declining or growing, "About 10 years ago there was more financial space
for experiments and alternative projects. Recently, economic problems have
meant cuts in venue-subsidies, making life hard for smaller places. This
has meant a shift towards the majors- the big venues, the major labels,
the huge festivals and commercial ventures. Life is definitely getting
more difficult for all us 'wannabes." In Holland, at least, cultural cuts
have been across the board. Jazz had less to lose in the first place (as
compared to classical music), but lost it anyway."
On the plus side for European performers, Leach explains that European
audiences tend to be more open to musical experimentation. "The main feature
of the UWO is that we only play our own original music. We're not American,
so we're not hindered by by "the jazz tradition", and are quite happy to
mix elements from folk/free/theatre/classical music- whatever."
The mixing of influences is apparent when listening to the varied textures
and colors that the two composers employ in their music, especially on
their CD "The Blue One". For example, Fuchs' fusion-infused work Lydisch
Blau is a hommage to the 20th-century artist Yves Klein, best known
for his monochromatic blue paintings. Its Pat Metheny-type approach features
Canada-based Christine Duncan vocalizing an arching melody in unison with
trumpets. A Wimbledon fan, Leach's Tiebreak musically captures the
ever-increasing pressure buildup in a tight tennis match with adventurous
sectional scoring and four soloists who push the intensity of their solos
towards the dramatic final chorus.
Fuchs observes that European audiences react to the UWO differently
by gender. "If the audience is mainly female, it's very easy- too easy.
If not, it gets tough- too tough." Regardless of the audience's gender
mix, she feels that "people watch 200-percent" when they see a woman composer
step up to conduct or perform.
Facing these subtle gender-related pressures together has created an
air of true collegiality within the United Women's Orchestra. Notes Leach,
"Because we're all women, there's an added confidence of knowing that any
commentary on personal playing or technique is honest and unclouded by
any sexist prejudice. We've all suffered from patronizing and/or discriminatory
behavior in the past, so it's refreshing not to have to tolerate this.
It's good to know that if someone tells you that you play sh** that they
mean exactly that!"
Much like their American counterparts, European women jazz musicians
are striving to perform at the highest professional level. Leach wraps
it up nicely when asked to summarize professional possibilities for women.,
"I think that opportunities are growing, but mainy in the sense that there
are less sexist-obstacles than there used to be. Women players now face
the same problems and limitations as men do. It's hard for me to compare
Europe with the USA as I have no first-hand experience on your side of
the water. I follow the jazzgrrls discussions, and my impression is that
it's more difficult for women in the USA. Audiences in the US seem to be
more conservative than over here, making it harder for new approaches and
attitudes in jazz to be accepted. I was amazed to hear Americans referring
to our music as 'avant-garde'. In comparison to, for example, George Gruntz
or Django Bates, we're actually quite mainstream!"
So, you go grrls. Take the jazz plunge. Women from around the world
have already jumped in and, despite the challenges, it sure is rewarding
and fun.